What is transference — and what is countertransference?
Why can a client respond to us as though we are somebody from their past? And what happens when the therapist has an unexpectedly strong reaction in return? Two important ideas, explained in a practical and human way.
Explore the relationship ↓A useful clinical lens, not a diagnosis or a claim that every feeling is caused by the past.
We never walk into a relationship with a completely blank page
Have you ever met somebody and instantly warmed to them, without knowing why? Or found yourself taking an immediate dislike to somebody who has done absolutely nothing wrong? There may be many explanations, but sometimes an earlier experience is influencing how we see the person standing in front of us.
In my original article I used a straightforward example. You meet a new boss who reminds you of your father. Perhaps the tone of their voice, the way they offer praise, or how they react when you make a mistake is familiar. Before long, you may find yourself trying too hard to please them—or preparing for criticism that has not actually arrived.
That is an everyday way of beginning to understand transference. In psychotherapy, the term describes a process where feelings, assumptions and expectations formed in earlier relationships are brought into a present relationship, often outside our conscious awareness. The idea has its roots in psychoanalysis, but similar relational patterns are recognised across different therapeutic approaches. [1]
Transference is not the same as imagining things, and it does not make someone's feelings false. If a client feels frightened, angry, attached or disappointed, that experience matters. The therapist’s job is not to dismiss it, but to remain curious about what is happening now and how to respond helpfully.
From Freud to contemporary psychotherapy
Sigmund Freud noticed that patients sometimes reacted towards him with feelings that appeared larger than, or quite different from, the situation in the consulting room. They might experience the therapist as a powerful parent, a disappointing authority figure or someone whose approval mattered enormously. Freud developed transference into a central part of psychoanalytic theory and treatment. [2]
The related concept of countertransference initially focused on the analyst's own unresolved feelings interfering with therapy. That understanding broadened. Paula Heimann's influential 1950 paper argued that a therapist's emotional reactions, carefully reflected upon, could also contribute to understanding the therapeutic relationship. [3]
Today, some psychodynamic therapists actively interpret transference as part of their work. Others, including practitioners of CBT and integrative therapy, may recognise patterns in thoughts, feelings and expectations without using the same language or methods. A review published in 2025 identified different instruments for assessing transference, while also noting that its relationship with outcomes still needs more research. [4]
Freud
Early psychoanalytic writings brought transference into the heart of thinking about the therapist–client relationship.
Paula Heimann
Helped shift discussion of therapist reactions from something simply to suppress towards something to examine responsibly.
Across approaches
Relational expectations and therapist responses matter in many settings, although the concepts are understood and used differently.
Transference is not always negative
When we hear the word transference, it is tempting to imagine anger or romantic attachment. In reality, the range is much wider. Sometimes clients feel safe very quickly; at other times, a perfectly reasonable question can leave them feeling judged or rejected.
Trust, warmth and reassurance
A client may experience us as unusually kind, wise or protective because we remind them of somebody who once helped them. This can support engagement, but idealising a therapist can make it difficult to disagree or become independent.
Fear, mistrust or anger
A client may expect criticism, rejection or control because a previous relationship taught them to anticipate those experiences. The emotional response is real even when the current therapist has not intended harm.
Approval and permission
A client may defer to the therapist as though speaking to a parent, teacher or powerful authority. They may agree with everything said in the room yet feel unable to voice doubts.
When boundaries matter most
Attraction, admiration or a wish for special closeness can arise in therapy. A therapist must not exploit, encourage or reciprocate such feelings, and must use supervision when necessary.
Competition and comparison
A person may compare themselves with others, feel overlooked or try to win approval in ways that reflect long-standing relationship expectations.
Closeness and distance together
A client may value therapy and still feel anxious about depending on the therapist. Human relationships are rarely as simple as positive versus negative.
My caution: not every strong emotion is transference. A client may be angry because we interrupted them, uneasy because an explanation was confusing, or disappointed because we made an error. We must take their present experience seriously rather than explain every difficulty away as a response to the past.
What is countertransference?
We ask clients to bring their genuine selves into therapy, but the therapist is a human being too. We have histories, expectations, worries, values and feelings. Countertransference asks us to notice when our own reactions may be influencing the work.
In its narrower, historical meaning, countertransference describes responses arising from the therapist’s own unresolved experiences. Broader contemporary definitions include the emotional, cognitive and behavioural responses that emerge in the therapeutic relationship, whether linked to the therapist's history, the interaction with the client or both. Researchers and practitioners do not all use the term in exactly the same way. [5]
It is important not to confuse countertransference with simply having empathy. Compassion, interest and concern are ordinary, necessary parts of our work. The concern begins when a feeling is unusually strong, repeatedly appears, drives a decision, or causes us to put our needs ahead of the client's.
The urge to rescue
Feeling compelled to solve everything, extend every session or become indispensable, instead of supporting the client's own decisions and resources.
Unexpected irritation
Feeling personally criticised when a client disagrees or repeatedly changes their mind; becoming defensive rather than curious.
Over-identification
Recognising so much of our own story in a client's situation that our history begins to shape what we think they should do.
Seeking approval
Needing the client to like us or praise our work, and avoiding necessary conversations because disagreement feels personally uncomfortable.
Over-protectiveness
Assuming a client is too fragile to explore choices, give feedback or make decisions, even when that assumption has not been checked.
Avoidance or withdrawal
Dreading appointments, becoming unusually distant or steering away from topics because something in the session touches our own difficulties.
There are times when our feelings offer a useful signal that something is happening between us and the client. But a feeling is information to examine, not evidence to act upon immediately. Supervision, reflective practice and personal support help us work out what belongs to the client, what may be our own and what may be happening in the relationship. [6]
Transference and countertransference: the distinction
| Question | Transference | Countertransference |
|---|---|---|
| Whose response? | Usually the client's. | The therapist's. |
| What happens? | Earlier expectations or relationship patterns influence the present interaction. | The therapist experiences emotional or behavioural reactions that may influence their judgement or responses. |
| Everyday illustration | “You sound like my father; I feel I must not disappoint you.” | “I feel responsible for protecting this client from every difficulty.” |
| Potential value | May help understand assumptions, trust and relationship patterns. | May alert the therapist to their own blind spots and what requires reflection. |
| Main risk | Past expectations may distort the present relationship or increase dependence. | The therapist may act to meet their own needs or lose professional objectivity. |
| Good response | Listen, check present reality, collaborate and respect autonomy. | Pause, reflect, seek supervision, reinforce boundaries and adjust if necessary. |
These are useful distinctions, but they are not rigid boxes. The same interaction may involve the client's expectations, the therapist's reactions and a genuine misunderstanding that needs an ordinary apology.
How it might appear in the therapy room
These are entirely fictional examples, not accounts of identifiable clients. They are there to help us think about how a small moment can carry a much larger meaning.
After one cancelled appointment, a client says, “Everyone leaves when I need them.” We apologise for the inconvenience, clarify arrangements and invite their experience. We do not immediately tell them they are transferring childhood abandonment onto us.
A client says, “You always know exactly what I should do.” Rather than enjoy the position of expert rescuer, we return agency: “I can help you explore options, but you know your life. What feels right to you?”
A client's situation reminds us of someone we love. We notice an urge to waive every fee or offer personal contact outside agreed hours. We consider what is clinically appropriate and take the question to supervision.
A small suggestion feels like an order to a client who has previously experienced controlling relationships. We invite feedback, explain our intention and offer genuine choice rather than insisting they misunderstand us.
A client questions whether hypnosis is helping, and we feel defensive. That feeling prompts reflection: are we trying to defend our method, or are we listening to feedback that might improve the client's care?
A client wants to socialise after the work ends. We acknowledge the value of the therapeutic relationship kindly, explain its professional limits and discuss endings appropriately, seeking supervision if needed.
The relationship is not a friendship, but it must still feel human
In the original article I wrote about the importance of clients liking their therapist. I still believe warmth and rapport matter enormously. Yet I would express the idea more carefully today: the client does not have to agree with everything we say, or feel obliged to like us, to deserve effective and respectful care.
Some clients will question us, disagree with us or take longer to feel safe. That does not mean we have failed or that they are resistant. A strong working alliance includes room for honest conversations about what is going well and what is not.
When trust is strained, a rupture may occur: a misunderstanding, a feeling of not being heard, a withdrawn response or a disagreement over goals. Repairing that rupture often matters more than winning the argument. This is also where transference and countertransference can become useful concepts—provided we do not use them to excuse our behaviour. [7]
See my related articles on the therapeutic relationship, rapport in the therapy room and apparent resistance in psychotherapy.
We can recognise an old pattern without making the whole session about the past
Solution Focused Hypnotherapy is not psychoanalysis, and I do not believe we need to interpret every client's past relationships to be helpful. Our work is collaborative, practical and oriented towards the future the person would prefer.
Yet we must be able to recognise what is happening in the room. If a client is desperate for my approval, that might affect whether they feel free to disagree. If I notice myself wanting to rescue somebody, I need to ask whether I am supporting their strengths or replacing their autonomy with my own preferences.
Sometimes a gentle, present-focused question is enough: “What would make our sessions feel more useful?” “What would you like me to understand?” or “How would you know you could ask me a difficult question?” At other times, deeper relational work may be appropriate with a practitioner trained for it.
Hypnosis itself does not remove the importance of boundaries or informed consent. If a client feels unusually dependent on us, fears losing control or wants to please us at any cost, our responsibility is to explain the process, check what they want and invite genuine choice—not use suggestibility to reinforce dependence.
Seven steps when you notice transference or countertransference
Notice, don't diagnose
Identify what you observed and how you felt. Keep a distinction between the event, your interpretation and the client's own explanation.
Check the present situation
Could the response make sense because of something you actually said or did? An accurate apology and a clearer explanation may be needed before any theoretical interpretation.
Stay calm and collaborative
Invite the client's perspective without embarrassment, judgement or pressure to agree with the therapist's account.
Keep boundaries predictable
Be clear about time, fees, contact between sessions, social media, gifts, touch, confidentiality and the professional purpose of the relationship.
Reflect on your own needs
Notice rescue impulses, irritation, attraction, avoidance or wanting to be especially liked. Ask whether these feelings are affecting the care you provide.
Use supervision appropriately
Discuss the dynamic in a confidential, ethical manner that protects identity and reflects the terms of consent, professional codes and legal duties.
Review, repair, adapt or refer
If the working alliance has been strained, address it. If objectivity, safety or scope of competence cannot be maintained, seek advice and arrange a considered referral or ending where appropriate.
Language that keeps the client at the centre
“It sounds as though that felt uncomfortable. Can you tell me what you heard in my question?”
“I'm glad this feels useful. What do you notice that you are doing differently?”
“I wonder if I've missed something important. I'd like to understand how you experienced that.”
“You are free to disagree with me. Your feedback helps us make sure this is the right work for you.”
“What support and resources do you already have outside this room that could help you continue?”
“I need to reflect on how best to support you. I'd like us to review what would be helpful going forward.”
These are illustrative phrases, not a script to impose. And where a boundary concern involves attraction, exploitation or serious impairment of objectivity, the answer is not simply a cleverly worded question; it is prompt ethical reflection, supervision and action.
Our reactions belong in supervision—not on the client's shoulders
As someone who works in clinical supervision, I see enormous value in giving ourselves a place to ask difficult questions. Why did I feel so protective of this person? Why did their disagreement upset me? Am I treating this client differently? Am I being guided by the client's goals, or by a need to feel successful?
These are not questions to be ashamed of. They are part of being a thoughtful professional. The important point is what we do with the answers. Supervision helps us explore different perspectives, recognise risk, identify blind spots and agree a safe plan. The literature on CBT supervision also describes how examining relationship patterns and therapist reactions may support clinical work. [8]
A useful supervision reflection: What did the client do or say? What did I feel? What did I do next? What alternative explanations have I considered? What does the client need from me now? Which boundaries or professional duties should guide my next action?
Boundaries are a form of care
The NCH's January 2026 Code of Ethical Conduct and Performance explicitly requires therapists to act in clients' best interests and maintain appropriate boundaries. It calls for supervision where attraction could affect the professional relationship and requires appropriate action if the therapist cannot remain objective. Similar expectations around client safety and professional boundaries appear in other professional standards. [9]
- Agree and explain session boundaries at the outset.
- Keep personal and professional social media separate.
- Do not seek emotional reassurance from clients.
- Never pursue romantic or sexual relationships with current clients.
- Use supervision before self-disclosure or significant boundary changes.
- Record clinically relevant decisions accurately and securely.
There is a power imbalance in the therapeutic relationship. We must not confuse gratitude with consent to greater intimacy, or interpret a client's attachment as permission to cross professional boundaries. The therapist is responsible for maintaining safety.
What does the research tell us?
Research recognises transference and countertransference as clinically meaningful concepts, but definitions and assessment methods vary. That matters when we interpret findings. A 2025 systematic review catalogued 15 transference assessment measures and called for further work on their usefulness across approaches. Review the paper.
Research into countertransference management suggests that noticing and reflecting on therapist reactions may benefit the working relationship, but it does not justify treating a clinician's feelings as a reliable diagnosis of what the client is experiencing. A 2024 empirical study examined changes in therapist responses and alliance and outcome; larger and more varied research is still needed. Read the study.
For everyday practice, the safest conclusion is modest: notice the relationship, remain open to other explanations, and use supervision and consent to keep the client’s interests first.
- [1] Original Best Mind Therapy article
- [2] Vecchio and colleagues (2025): systematic review of transference assessment
- [3] British Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy: managing therapy relationships
- [4] Prasko and colleagues (2022): managing transference in CBT supervision
- [5] American Psychological Association (2025): countertransference in clinical practice
- [6] National Council for Hypnotherapy: Code of Ethical Conduct and Performance (updated 2026)
- [7] National Board for Hypnotherapy: ethical standards and supervision
- [8] Library of Congress: Freud and the early transference model
- [9] Abargil and Tishby (2024): countertransference, alliance and outcome
- [10] Heimann (1950): On Counter-Transference, historical paper record
Transference and countertransference: common questions
What is transference in simple terms?
Transference is when feelings, assumptions or expectations shaped by earlier relationships influence how somebody responds to a person in the present, including a therapist. It can be positive, negative or mixed.
What is countertransference?
Countertransference refers to the therapist’s emotional, cognitive or behavioural reactions in the therapeutic relationship. Definitions vary: some focus on reactions linked to the therapist’s own history, while broader approaches consider the full range of responses.
Is transference always a problem?
No. Feeling reassured, hopeful, doubtful or wary of a therapist is not automatically unhealthy. It becomes clinically important when past expectations strongly shape the present relationship or interfere with the client’s autonomy and progress.
Can transference happen in Solution Focused Hypnotherapy?
Yes. Relationship expectations can appear in any talking therapy, including Solution Focused work. Recognising them does not mean the therapist must change to psychoanalysis or actively interpret the client’s childhood.
What are signs of countertransference?
Possible signs include unusually strong rescue impulses, dread before a session, irritation, over-identification, wanting to be specially liked, frequent rule bending or difficulty maintaining agreed boundaries. None alone proves countertransference.
What if a client develops romantic feelings for a therapist?
The therapist should remain calm, avoid shaming or reciprocating, restate professional boundaries where necessary and seek supervision. Romantic or sexual involvement with a current client is incompatible with safe professional practice.
Does a therapist have to like every client?
A therapist does not need to feel close personal affection for every client. What matters is respectful, competent, compassionate practice and an effective working alliance. If strong reactions affect objectivity, they should be addressed in supervision.
Should a therapist tell the client about countertransference?
Not automatically. The therapist should first reflect and seek supervision. Any self-disclosure should have a clear clinical purpose, fit the therapeutic approach, and serve the client rather than relieve the therapist’s own discomfort.
What if the therapeutic relationship feels uncomfortable?
The client may ask questions, give feedback, request changes, seek another practitioner or stop therapy. Therapists should invite feedback and respond non-defensively, while recognising any safeguarding or professional concerns.
Warmth, awareness and professional distance can exist together
I began the original article by explaining how somebody may remind us of a person from our past. That remains a useful introduction. What matters professionally is what we do when those feelings enter the therapy room.
We don't need to become cold or remote to maintain boundaries. We can be friendly, empathetic and interested, while still being honest, reflective and clear about the purpose of therapy. We should aim for clients to feel safe enough to speak frankly, confident enough to disagree and increasingly able to use their own strengths beyond the sessions.
If you would like to explore my approach, you can read about psychotherapy at Best Mind Therapy or visit the contact page. For a question about this educational article, email